As someone with wide feet, I can attest to the pain of finding the right summer sandals. I lust after those By Far strappy mules as much as the next fashion editor, but I just know that I’m going to look like one of Cinderella’s stepsisters trying to shove my foot into that sexy slimline silhouette. So after a lifetime of summers spent suffering in too-tight shoes, I’ve done all of us a favor and tracked down five brands that make sandals for wide feet that are comfortable and cute.

Luckily, with the return of the flip-flop and the rise of the fashion-forward Teva (more on that in a minute), there have never been more wide-feet-friendly options on the market—and at a range of price points to boot. Read on to discover the five brands stocking your summer sandal wardrobe.