Beauty is both cyclical and seasonal. It’s the reason why decades-old makeup looks and hairstyles are relevant. It’s also the reason why there’s so much emphasis on swapping out different skincare and makeup products whenever the weather changes.

You know the drill. When the temperatures rise, it’s time to switch from a rich winter moisturizer to a lightweight summer formula. Maybe you’ll even retire your creamy cleanser and opt for an oil-controlling gel one instead. But what about the less obvious seasonal swaps? I reached out to my fellow Who What Wear editors to ask which products they’re retiring for summer (and why) and which ones they’re adding to their routines. As beauty experts, I knew their answers would inspire me to make some changes in my own routine, and I was right. Ahead, see every summer beauty swap our editors are making this year.